This page may contain affiliate links.
Some links on this page are affiliate links, meaning I may earn a commission if you sign up (at no extra cost to you). This never influences my ratings or recommendations.
The Verdict
Campaign Monitor wins for traditional email marketing with advanced automation and enterprise features.
beehiiv excels for content creators and newsletter publishers who need built-in monetization and growth tools. Your choice depends on whether you prioritize email marketing depth or all-in-one newsletter publishing.
Before making your final decision, check my Campaign Monitor Pricing and beehiiv Pricing pages for the latest plan details and features included per tier.
If neither feels like the perfect fit, explore Campaign Monitor alternatives or beehiiv alternatives.
Choose Campaign Monitor if
- +Businesses needing advanced email automation
- +Agencies managing multiple client campaigns
- +Companies requiring enterprise-grade features
- +Teams focused purely on email marketing
Choose beehiiv if
- +Newsletter publishers and content creators
- +Solo creators wanting to monetize content
- +Publishers needing built-in website functionality
- +Users prioritizing audience growth tools
Pricing
Which one costs more?
Here's how the pricing compares between these platforms: For the full plan-by-plan breakdown with annual discounts, see my Campaign Monitor Pricing and beehiiv Pricing guides.
| Plan / Tier | Campaign Monitor | beehiiv | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Free/Launch | Free | $0 | Basic features, limited subscribers |
| Starter/Scale | $21/mo | $43/mo | More features and higher subscriber limits |
| Professional/Max | Contact for pricing | $96/mo | Advanced features and unlimited users |
| Enterprise | Contact for pricing | Custom pricing | Custom solutions for large organizations |
Buddy's Take on Pricing
Campaign Monitor offers more affordable entry-level pricing with clearer tier structures. beehiiv's pricing is higher but includes more comprehensive features like website building and monetization tools that would require separate services elsewhere. Keep in mind that the cheapest plan is not always the best value.
Consider which features you actually need and how pricing changes as your subscriber list grows. My Campaign Monitor Pricing and beehiiv Pricing pages have the complete tier-by-tier breakdowns.
Features
Capability comparison
A traditional email marketing platform vs. a modern newsletter-publishing engine. Campaign Monitor gives you pixel-perfect email templates and agency collaboration tools. beehiiv gives you a website, referral programs, and ad monetization. They barely overlap beyond 'sending emails to subscribers.'
| Capability | Campaign Monitor | beehiiv |
|---|---|---|
| Email Templates | ★ | ● |
| Automation Workflows | ★ | ○ |
| Website Builder | ✗ | ★ |
| Built-in Monetization | ✗ | ★ |
| A/B Testing | ★ | ● |
| Referral System | ✗ | ★ |
| Analytics & Reporting | ★ | ● |
| AI Writing Tools | ● | ★ |
| API Access | ★ | ● |
| Custom Domains | ✓ | ✓ |
Campaign Monitor excels in traditional email marketing features with its advanced automation workflows, comprehensive A/B testing, and detailed analytics. The platform offers professional template designs and segmentation tools that appeal to businesses focused purely on email campaigns. Its visual journey designer makes complex automation accessible, while features like dynamic content and time zone sending cater to marketing needs that require personalization.
However, Campaign Monitor lacks modern creator-focused features like built-in monetization or website building capabilities. beehiiv takes a different approach by combining newsletter creation with website building and monetization tools. Its standout features include a built-in ad network, referral system, and subscription management with 0% fees. The platform excels at helping creators grow their audience through recommendation networks and boosts, while AI writing tools help with content creation.
beehiiv's 3D analytics provide unique insights into subscriber behavior, though the automation capabilities are more basic compared to Campaign Monitor.
Want to master email marketing fundamentals? My comprehensive email marketing guide covers deliverability, automation, and list-building strategies.
Who It's For
Who should choose which?
Choose Campaign Monitor if you...
- +You need advanced email automation workflows
- +Professional template design is a priority
- +You're managing campaigns for multiple clients
- +Detailed analytics and reporting are essential
- +You want established enterprise features
- +Email marketing is your primary focus
Choose beehiiv if you...
- +You're a newsletter publisher or content creator
- +You want built-in monetization options
- +Website building is part of your needs
- +Audience growth tools are important
- +You prefer modern, creator-focused features
- +All-in-one publishing platform appeals to you
Final recommendation
The bottom line
Choose Campaign Monitor if you need an email marketing platform with advanced automation and professional features. It's ideal for businesses, agencies, and organizations that prioritize detailed email campaigns and detailed analytics. The platform excels in traditional email marketing scenarios where automation workflows and template design matter most.
Choose beehiiv if you're a content creator, newsletter publisher, or entrepreneur looking to build and monetize an audience. Its all-in-one approach combining newsletters, websites, and monetization tools makes it perfect for creators who want to focus on content rather than managing multiple platforms.
The built-in referral system and ad network are particularly valuable for growing and monetizing subscriber bases. If neither Campaign Monitor nor beehiiv feels like exactly what you need, browse my best email marketing software roundup for a wider look at the market.
I also have dedicated pages for Campaign Monitor alternatives and beehiiv alternatives if you want to explore platforms that compete directly with either option.
For similar head-to-head matchups, check out beehiiv vs ActiveCampaign, beehiiv vs Brevo, beehiiv vs GetResponse.
FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions
It depends on your needs. Campaign Monitor is better for traditional email marketing with advanced automation, while beehiiv excels for newsletter publishing with built-in monetization.
Campaign Monitor has lower starting prices at $21/month versus beehiiv's $43/month, but beehiiv includes more comprehensive features like website building.
Yes, you can export your subscriber list from Campaign Monitor and import it into beehiiv, though some automation workflows will need to be rebuilt.
beehiiv is generally more beginner-friendly with its all-in-one approach and modern interface, while Campaign Monitor has a steeper learning curve but more advanced features.
Yes, both Campaign Monitor and beehiiv support custom domains for emails and websites.
beehiiv wins decisively with built-in ad networks, subscription management, and digital product sales, while Campaign Monitor lacks monetization tools.
More on these tools
Joonas Rotko
Author & founder of That Marketing Buddy
I score marketing software for AI-stack fit (MCP, API, agent-readiness), backed by 10+ years in digital marketing. This comparison is based on structured data from 60+ tools in the marketing software category.
This page may contain affiliate links. I earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This never influences the comparison.
Try Campaign Monitor
Try beehiiv